1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. Investment

Convertible Note, SAFE or Equity: What to Use in a First Round

Compare the Brazilian convertible note, the SAFE and priced equity: how each works in Brazil, what cap and discount mean and which fits a first funding round.

Investment

In a first funding round in Brazil, three paths come up again and again: the mútuo conversível, a convertible loan that turns into equity later and works much like a convertible note; the SAFE, an American contract with similar logic that is not debt; and priced equity, where the investor becomes a shareholder right away. The convertible note is popular for small Brazilian rounds because it postpones the valuation debate and keeps the investor off the shareholder register until conversion. The right choice depends on how the company is structured, how big the round is and what the lead investor requires.

How the Brazilian convertible note works

The mútuo conversível is a loan agreement, a contract type governed by Brazil's Civil Code, with a clause that allows or requires the amount to convert into equity. The investor lends money today, and the debt becomes quotas or shares when an agreed event happens.

The terms you will negotiate:

  • Amount and maturity date.
  • Interest, if any, which usually converts as well.
  • Conversion triggers: a qualified round, maturity or a sale of the company.
  • Valuation cap, the maximum valuation used at conversion.
  • Discount on the price of the round that triggers conversion.
  • What happens at maturity if no round has taken place: automatic conversion, extension or repayment.

That last point deserves attention. Because it is legally a debt, a note without a clear conversion clause at maturity can force the company to repay the money exactly when cash is tight. Brazil's Startup Legal Framework, Complementary Law 182/2021, recognizes the convertible loan as an investment instrument under which, before conversion, the investor is not considered a partner and is not liable for the company's debts, except in cases of willful misconduct, fraud or sham transactions.

Valuation cap and discount: the math in practice

The cap and discount reward early investors by letting them pay less per share than the next round's investors. At conversion, the investor gets whichever is better for them.

Imagine a R$ 500,000 note (R$ is the Brazilian real) with a R$ 5 million cap and a 20% discount. If the next round is priced at a R$ 10 million pre-money valuation, the discount would bring the price to R$ 8 million, but the cap limits it to R$ 5 million. The investor converts at R$ 5 million and ends up with roughly 10%, depending on how the contract defines the calculation base.

Now imagine the round is priced at R$ 6 million pre-money. The discount brings it to R$ 4.8 million, below the cap, so the investor converts at the discount. Run these scenarios before signing, especially when more than one convertible is outstanding.

The SAFE and how it is used in Brazil

The SAFE, a Simple Agreement for Future Equity, was created by the US accelerator Y Combinator in 2013. It gives the investor the right to receive equity in a future round, with a cap and discount, but it is not debt: there is no interest and no maturity date.

Brazilian law has no specific provision for the SAFE. It is used most naturally when the startup has a holding company abroad, in jurisdictions where the document is standard. Adapted versions exist for Brazilian companies, but Brazilian law looks at a contract's substance rather than its name. A poorly adapted version may be treated differently from what the parties intended, including for tax purposes. If you use one, work with a Brazilian lawyer who knows the instrument.

Priced equity: the investor becomes a shareholder now

In a priced round, the price is set. The investor pays for quotas or shares and joins the shareholder base immediately, through an amendment to the contrato social (the articles of association) in a Ltda, or a share subscription in an S.A. (corporation). A shareholders' agreement comes with it, covering information rights, preferences and exit rules.

The advantages are clarity and finality: everyone knows what they own from day one. The drawbacks are higher legal cost, longer negotiation and the need to agree on a valuation when it is hardest to defend. As a shareholder, the investor is also more exposed to the company's risks, which is why many Brazilian angels prefer convertible instruments early on.

Side-by-side comparison

CriterionConvertible note (mútuo)SAFEPriced equity
NatureLoan that may convert into equityRight to future equity, no specific provision in Brazilian lawImmediate equity
Investor becomes shareholderOnly at conversionOnly at conversionImmediately
ValuationDeferred, with cap and discountDeferred, with cap and discountSet in the round
Interest and maturityUsually yesNoNot applicable
Legal cost and timeLowerLower, if the structure allowsHigher
Typical fitSmall rounds in a Brazilian companyStartups with a holding abroadFund-led rounds

How to choose for your round

Before deciding, answer these questions:

  1. Is the company a Ltda, an S.A. or does it have a holding outside Brazil?
  2. How large is the round and how many investors are coming in?
  3. Does the lead investor have a preference or requirement for a specific instrument?
  4. How long do you expect until the next round, which will trigger conversion?
  5. What are the tax effects for the company and for the investor? Depending on the structure, Brazilian taxes such as IOF (a tax on financial transactions) and income tax may apply, and this should be confirmed with an accountant.

When the investor also contributes operations, the instrument has to reflect both. That is the case with Bridgemoon Capital, based in São Paulo, which invests in startups and takes equity in digital businesses as a partner, bringing software development, marketing and payment processing: the contract should cover both the money and the deliverables, with clear deadlines and responsibilities.

Frequently asked questions

Does a convertible note have to be repaid if it does not convert?

It depends on the contract. If it provides for automatic conversion at maturity, the amount turns into equity even without a new round. If it does not, the investor may be entitled to demand repayment with interest, which weighs on the startup's cash. That is why the maturity clause is one of the most important in the negotiation.

Is a SAFE legally valid in Brazil?

A contract with SAFE-like logic can be signed in Brazil, but there is no specific legal figure by that name, and its treatment depends on how the document is drafted. For Brazilian companies, many founders prefer the convertible loan, which Brazil's Startup Legal Framework expressly recognizes. Either way, the drafting should be done by a lawyer.

What is a qualified round?

It is the funding round that, under the contract, triggers automatic conversion of convertible notes and SAFEs into equity. It is usually defined by a minimum amount of new money raised, so that a small round cannot force conversion on terms that are bad for earlier investors.